How Do College Coaches Determine Who Makes the Traveling Squad: Qualifying Rounds, Coach’s Selection, or a Combination of Both?
Most college golf teams have at least three or four extra players on their rosters and, in some cases, as many as 10 extra players. While the vast majority of college tournaments feature a five-person team format (and possibly one or two additional individual competitors), coaches are faced with arguably the toughest task of their profession – how to determine who makes the traveling squad. This topic is heavily discussed among coaches as they try to balance fairness with competitiveness. Ultimately, the goal is to have the five best players represent the school in each tournament, while also ensuring players are rewarded for their hard work, good attitudes, and accomplishments in both tournament and qualifying rounds.
There are some coaches who maintain only qualifying rounds should be used to determine who will represent their school in the team’s next competition. While this is a totally objective system, there are a few arguments against it. First, qualifying on a team’s home golf course does not perfectly represent the tournament conditions the team will face. Also, upperclassmen have a distinct advantage over freshmen, having played the school’s home course for several years. Oftentimes, a player needs to miss team practice (or a qualifying round) due to a legitimate reason, such as academics, illness, or injury. In these cases, a coach who makes their decision based solely on qualifying rounds may end up leaving one of their best players at home for the next tournament.
Another school of thought some coaches employ is to merely “select” the players for the team’s next competition. Some of these coaches will have their players play several qualifying rounds but not guarantee any spots. Instead they take into account a player’s past tournament record, who is working the hardest and currently playing the best (in their opinion), how certain players may fare on the course they are scheduled to play and, in some cases, who they have the most scholarship money invested in. Occasionally, this can create frustration among some players if they are shooting low scores in qualifying rounds (relative to other team members) yet not being selected to represent the team. Generally, past tournament results will have the most impact on a coach’s selection.
The most common system coaches use to determine who will make their traveling squad is a “hybrid” of the two previously mentioned approaches. A coach may conduct a multi-round qualifier that guarantees a specific number of spots (one or more) and then select the remaining players once the qualifier has concluded. Players should keep in mind that selections may have very little to do with their qualifying scores, and just because they finished among the top five finishers, there is no guarantee they will receive a coach’s pick. Players may be skipped over depending on whom the coach wants to select. This occurs in both the Ryder Cup and President’s Cup selections as well. One final component of this hybrid approach may include opportunities to earn exemptions if certain criteria are met. Examples may include top finishes or wins in previous college tournaments (could apply to the entire team); recently qualifying for a major amateur tournament, such as the U.S. Amateur or U.S. Women’s Amateur; or earning a post-season honor, such as “All America” from the previous season.
Regardless of which system your future college coach uses to determine his team’s traveling squad, shooting low scores, working hard, and maintaining a positive attitude are the best ways to ultimately make the team.
Red Numbers Golf®
Parents and Junior Golfers New to Going to College? Start Here!Are You Prepared to Pursue College Golf?
Coaches Finding & Evaluating PlayersWhen is the Best Time to Communicate with Coaches?
When Should Junior Golf Prospects Expect to Receive Offers from College Coaches?
Should I Communicate a Poor Performance to a College Coach?
Are You Waiting for Tournament Success Before Contacting College Golf Coaches?
Who Should Speak When Meeting with Coaches – Parents or the Student-Athlete?
Do College Coaches Use Swing Videos To Evaluate Recruits?
Do Coaches Really Care About Academics?
Do You Have the Game to Play College Golf?
How Do College Coaches Work Junior Tournaments?
How Do College Golf Coaches Discover Talent?
Finding the Right School - Your "Best Fit"What Can You Learn from College Golf’s Post-Season Championships?
How Do College Golf Scores Compare to Junior Golf Scores?
How Do I Know Which Schools Are “Best Fits” for Me?
How Do I Remain Proactive in Identifying My “Best Fit”?
Is a Walk-On Opportunity the “Best Fit” for Me?
What Are the Real Keys to a Successful College Golf Recruiting Experience?
What Useful Information Can I Research on a Golf Team's Website?
When Should Junior Golfers Begin Visiting and Researching Colleges?
What’s the Story on Division II and Division III Golf Programs?
Are Unofficial Visits to College Campuses Necessary?
Should Junior Golfers Attend Collegiate Tournaments?
Just How Big is College Golf?
What questions should I ask a college coach during a campus visit?
Where Should I Attend College to Study and Play Golf?
Playing in CollegeHow Do College Coaches Determine Who Makes the Traveling Squad: Qualifying Rounds, Coach’s Selection, or a Combination of Both?
Repeating a Grade in High School or Pursuing a Post-Grad Year – Part Two
Repeating a Grade in High School or Pursuing a Post-Grad Year – Part One
Are College Golfers Expected to Take Part in a Conditioning Program?
What’s the Story on Club Golf?
What Is Your Ideal Time Commitment for Playing Golf in College?
What Can You Expect From a College Golf Tournament?
Are You Practicing to Play the Odds?
Am I good enough to play Division I golf?
What does it mean to Redshirt?
How Do I Prepare for my Freshman Year in College?
How Important Is Time Management for Student-Athletes at the Collegiate Level?
What Is a Typical Week Like in the Life of a College Golfer?
Is College Golf an Individual Sport?
What are the main differences between junior golf and college golf?
What Commitment Level is Necessary for Junior Golfers to Become Successful Collegiate Student-Athletes?
Playing Junior GolfDo You Know the Rules of Amateur Status?
What Academic Habits Are Essential for a High School Student-Athlete?
Are There Benefits to Playing on a High School Golf Team?
Is playing a practice round important?
Is There More to Golf Than a Score?
You Have Completed the College Placement Process—Now What?
Is It a Good Idea To Withdraw After a Poor Round?
How Can a Junior Golfer Improve His Practice Sessions?
Promoting Yourself – Being VisibleWith spring around the corner, am I staying active in the college recruiting process?
What Should Junior Golfers Do Before Their High School Years To Start Pursuing College Golf?
How Can Golf Recruits Maximize Visibility Among College Coaches?
When and How Should I Initiate a Phone Call to a College Coach?
Is Your Written Communication to Coaches Sending the Right Message?
What Information Should Prospects Send to College Golf Coaches?
Will Playing AJGA Events Increase My Chances of Earning a College Scholarship?
What Should Recruits Say When Coaches Call Them?
College Recruitment Timeline - Part 2
College Recruitment Timeline - Part 1
Recruiting & ScholarshipsAre You Prepared to Pursue College Golf?
How Should I Respond When a Coach Makes an Offer?
How Do the NCAA’s Recent Rules Changes Affect You?
Is the College Recruiting Process Putting Too Much Pressure on You?
When Should I Apply to Colleges?
What is the Purpose of the NCAA Eligibility Center?
What Is a Parent’s Role During a Campus Visit?
Can Facebook or a Social Network Site Affect How I am Recruited?
What Should I Do if I Didn’t Sign a National Letter of Intent in the Early Signing Period?
What Questions Should I Be Prepared to Answer During a Campus Visit?
What Are the Most Frequently Asked Questions Concerning Scholarships?
How do I know if a School is Really Interested in Recruiting Me?
How do Players Verbally Commit to Schools so Early in the Process?
As a Rising Senior Is It Too Late To Be Recruited?
What is a Parent's Role in the Recruiting Process?
When Should Junior Golfers Sign the NLI?
What is a Full Scholarship?